From Fairies to Witches: An Interview with Sasha Peyton Smith
Morgan & Sam || Just One More Page Podcast || May 5th 2026
What do you get when you mix Victorian high society, mischievous fae, and dangerously irresistible games? The Rose Bargain! We’re beyond thrilled to welcome its author, New York Times bestselling writer Sasha Peyton Smith, to the podcast and step inside the enchanting world she created.
In this episode, we discuss Sasha’s writing career, the inspiration behind The Rose Bargain duology, and how she brought its complex characters to life.
A Warning Before You Listen: This Episode Contains Spoilers for The Rose Bargain.
Did you always want to be a writer growing up, or was it something that just happened?
Sasha: No, I didn't always want to be a writer, which all of my friends who are professional writers knew from the moment they could hold a pen that it was the only thing they wanted to do. That wasn't the case for me. I was always a really big reader, but I spent my childhood thinking I wanted to be a lot of different things. I wanted to be a lawyer, then a teacher, then a fashion designer, and then a doctor. I went to school thinking I'd be a doctor. I majored in biology in undergrad and decided fairly quickly that I didn't want to be a doctor, but I still really liked science. I ended up getting my master's degree in public health, and I was working in pediatric healthcare for most of my twenties.
I wrote The Witch Haven, my debut novel, in grad school, kind of as a project to prove to myself that I could do it. I never identified as a writer. I think it felt like something I wasn't allowed to want. I fancied myself a practical person, and it didn't seem like a very practical dream. But then I was going home from college and writing tens of thousands of words of secret fanfiction. It wasn't until graduate school, when I was alone in a new city and didn't have many friends yet, that the idea for what became The Witch Haven came to me. I thought, "How hard could it be? I've read thousands of books!"
The answer is incredibly hard.
But I'm stubborn, and by the time I started, I wanted to prove to myself that I could finish. I ended up, through a great stroke of luck, getting into an incredible mentorship program, signing with my incredible agent, and getting this book deal. My life ended up being so much bigger and better than I ever let myself hope for.
What inspired you to write The Rose Bargain after The Witch Haven series?
Sasha: The Witch Haven was my debut duology. That series did well. It was a New York Times bestseller, and I had earned out my advance. I thought I was an A+ student. I did everything I was supposed to do. Then I went to sell my next book to my publisher, and they didn't want it. I was dropped by my publisher. It's not personal, and I know that now. That's just showbiz, baby! But it felt really devastating at the time. I was kind of shattered by it because, before that, I'd had a fairy-tale experience. I hadn't really faced a big failure yet. I was home for the holidays, kind of nursing my wounds and having a pity party. I was thinking I might never write professionally again. I was in my childhood bedroom, which still had all the books I loved as a teenager, like Delirium, A Great and Terrible Beauty, The Hunger Games, and Twilight. I decided that if nobody was ever going to read what I wrote again, I might as well write something that made me feel the way those books made me feel.
The idea of "What if the Queen of England was a fairy?" struck me like lightning, which is a very silly idea! But I decided to give in to that. I wanted to write the most self-indulgent book possible to see if writing could still bring me joy.I threw every single thing I loved into The Rose Bargain. All my favorite tropes! We have just one bed, a brother love triangle, longing from across a crowded ballroom, a massive cast of girls, and ball gown descriptions. I did not deny myself anything. Any single thing I could put in that seemed fun, I put into this book. And that is how The Rose Bargain was born.
With the popularity of fae in romantasy, did you feel intimidated about writing your own version of fairies?
Sasha: Not really. I knew I was writing a YA romantasy, and I also knew I was going to pull pretty directly from English and Irish fairy mythology. My grandmother was English, so I grew up with a lot of fairy stories. In her stories, fairies are very uncanny and kind of creepy. If you hear music in the woods, no, you don't! If somebody comes to you with a deal that's too good to be true, you don't make it. They were distinctly inhuman and things to be cautious of. I love that version of fairies. I love fairies as a kind of malevolent presence.
I find immortality completely horrifying. I know I would never write a classic immortal love interest. Not that I think they're bad! I love those books. But personally, the idea of living forever is my absolute nightmare. I thought a lot about what immortality would do to Queen Mor living among humans and how temporary humans must feel to her. What does that do to your sense of empathy and kindness? I think, above all things, she's really bored. That's a really interesting place to create a villain from. I also think that's what's so fun about fantasy. You get to see fifteen different takes on vampires and twenty different takes on fairies. I really like seeing where people pull from mythology that everybody knows and where people create their own mythologies.
Was Ivy's close and protective relationship with her sister something you intentionally planned?
Sasha: I knew that I wanted to write a sister book. I'm number three of four children. I have an older brother and two sisters, so I'm in the middle of a group of three sisters.
Even before I had the idea for The Rose Bargain, I knew I wanted to explore sister relationships in my next work. There's nothing like a sister relationship. There are very few people in the world I would absolutely kill for that I also want to kill sometimes! Especially in your adolescent years, having a sister can be so agonizing because they reflect the parts of you that you find frustrating back to yourself. That's absolutely true when it comes to Ivy and Lydia's relationship. They share so many of the same faults. In learning to forgive Lydia, Ivy has to learn to forgive herself, too.
Their relationship was always meant to be the heart of this book. Their relationship is definitely the heart of The Thorn Queen, too. Lydia is on the page even more, gets her own POV chapters, and goes on her own journey beside Ivy. I knew their relationship was going to be the thing I wanted to explore the most: this deep love they have for each other that's also tangled in some pretty deep resentment.
One Last Page...
Want to check out the rest of our conversation with Sasha? Where we test her 1800 slang, discuss the secrets behind The Rose Bargain, and dive deeper into some spoiler filled with questions about, Ivy, the fairy queen, and what readers can expect from The Thorn Queen.
Listen to our full interview with Sasha Peyton Smith on Just One More Page!
Many thanks to Sasha Peyton Smith for joining us to discuss her novels!