Bad Boys, Deadly Sins, and Happily Ever After with Kait Ballenger

Morgan & Sam || Just One More Page Podcast 

April 6th 2025

Listen Now

What happens when the seven deadly sins trade the fiery pits of Hell for the glamorous streets of New York City? According to author Kate Ballenger, you get billionaire celebrities, dangerous secrets, and a whole lot of temptation.

Known for her Seven Range Shifters and Rogue Brotherhood series, Kate has a particular talent for crafting morally gray heroes, irresistible bad boys, and redemption arcs that leave readers wanting more.

We had the pleasure of welcoming award-winning paranormal and dark romance author Kate Ballenger to Just One More Page to discuss her newest novel, Original Sinner, the first installment in her planned trilogy.

What was your inspiration for starting this series? Did you have a dream, did something click, or did you read a book that inspired the idea?

Kait Ballenger: For all my ideas, when I'm working on a new project, I keep the guiding idea that I'm never going to write something I wouldn't love to read as a reader. At the time, I was really into reading a lot of Hades and Persephone retellings. I thought, "I would love to write a Hades and Persephone retelling, but there are so many of them. How could I do something similar but make it different and fresh?"

Then my thought was, "Well, Lucifer is basically the Christian Hades," and the idea was born from there.

I really wanted that similar vibe but to be able to do it in my own way and depart from the retellings somewhat. I wanted to give the same feelings as the Hades and Persephone stories without actually being Hades and Persephone

When you sit down to write your stories, are you someone who plans the series from beginning to end, or are you more of a pantser who figures out the details as you go? Or are you somewhere in between?

Kait Ballenger: I've kind of vacillated between the two over the course of my career. Early on, when I was writing the Rogue Brotherhood series, I was very much a pantser. Then, around the time I was writing my Seven Range Shifters books, I leaned a little more into plotting. I was somewhere in between, where I would plot out the main plot beats but ultimately be more of a discovery writer in between.

With the Original Sinner series, this was really me going back to my roots of being a total pantser and discovery writer, just letting it go where I wanted it to go. This book was very much a joy project for me. I thought, "I'm just going to put everything I love in a book, and who cares if anyone likes it? I like it, right?" It was really an exercise in doing what I wanted to do, and it paid off well.

Do you always like to write morally gray characters? With the other deadly sins eventually getting their own stories, do you think they'll be darker characters, or might we get a golden retriever boyfriend?

Kait Ballenger: I'm not sure, because overall, I tend to write in the range of bad boys with a heart of gold to morally gray. That's where I tend to reside. I love a good redemption arc. When you can make the morally gray bad guy turn just a little bit good in the end good enough for her, right? He's a little good for his heroine or whoever he's paired with. I could foresee myself writing a little bit darker, but not too much. I still like them to be redeemable in the end. But I never say never, especially because I'm a pantser and the ideas develop as I go. I really do like the idea of pairing Greed, who's one of the seven deadly sins in the series, with a golden retriever type of character. I feel like she deserves a golden retriever! She's got total black cat energy, so I think that would be a good pairing.

Was there ever a point in your publishing journey when you considered giving up? And what advice would you give aspiring writers who are dealing with rejection or whose books aren't performing as well as they'd hoped?

Kait Ballenger: I can't say there was ever really a point when I felt like I should give up, but I think that's just the nature of my personality. I'm a very tenacious person, and I don't take no for an answer easily. I imagine other writers probably would have felt like that at that point, but it just made me more stubborn. I was like, "Nope, I'm not going to let this keep me down. I'm just going to figure out a way of going forward."

I guess that would be my advice to younger and aspiring authors. It's really a longevity game when it comes to the publishing industry, which requires a lot of resilience. There are going to be inevitable times when you have ups in your career and then downs in your career. You just have to pick yourself up and brush yourself off.

The best thing you can do for yourself is to keep going and keep believing in yourself.

We heard that you connected with your literary agent through an elevator encounter, which we found fascinating. Could you tell us how that happened?

Kait Ballenger: I like to say that I found my agent via a literal elevator pitch! I was at a Romance Writers of America conference in New York City. I was a little aspiring baby author trying to find an agent, and I happened to be on the elevator with a woman named Mary Sue Seymour, who has since passed away. She was the president and head of the Seymour Agency, and I knew a writer from my local RWA chapter who was represented by her. I introduced myself, and she asked me the customary question, "Oh, well, what do you write?" I gave her my pitch, and she said, "Well, I don't represent that, but my co-agent Nicole does."

She gave me Nicole's card, and I ended up emailing her when I got home from the conference. She requested my full manuscript, and I sent it off to her. Twenty-four hours later, she called me and said she wanted to represent me because she'd spent the whole day in bed reading it from start to finish. That was like a dream!

As a starting writer, you want that kind of enthusiasm from your agent and from the people you're going to be working with on your team.

Many thanks to Kait Ballenger for joining us to discuss her novels!

One Last Page...

Join us for the rest of the conversation with Kait Ballenger as we go more indepth into her novel Original Sinner and what can readers expect in her next installment. Or what Kait decided to give her deadly sins a little mafia inspired spin.

Listen to our full interview with Kait Ballenger on Just One More Page!